So you’re finally ready to start that long-delayed wood deck on the back of the house. It will be a nice addition to your home, and national estimates show that approximately 70% of the cost of a deck will be recovered when you resell your home.
But one question keeps nagging at you - what do I build it out of? There are a quite a few building materials available that are appropriate for exterior decks. Choosing the right one means taking into consideration your budget, aesthetics, and carpentry ability.
Pressure-Treated Lumber
This is the least expensive option, and is widely available across the country. Pressure-treatment consists of impregnating lumber of various sizes with an insect and rot resistant chemical. Manufacturers claim that lumber treated in this manner will remain serviceable for as long as thirty years. The result of this treatment is that the wood (most often a variety of pine) has a somewhat greenish tint and a high moisture content. This moisture content shows up in the back-breaking weight of the wood (especially the 4×4’s), and in its workability. As it dries out, pressure-treated lumber also tends to cup or bow more than other wood, and thin members (such as 2×2’s) can sometimes suffer from strange bending.
Nevertheless, pressure-treated wood remains popular because of its strength and the variety of sizes it comes in, typically: 6×6, 4×4, 2×10, 2×8, 2×6, 2×4, and 2×2. For decking, a popular 5/4 x 6 board is available with rounded edges. This material can span 24” and comes in lengths of up to 12’ to avoid unpleasant butt joints (where two boards meet at the end).
The major rap on pressure-treated lumber is the appearance. The green tint fades after a couple of years, leaving an uneven gray tone to the lumber. Attempts to stain pressure-treated wood never really seem to result in a satisfactory appearance. Semi-opaque stains seem to work best, in that they eliminate much of the unpleasant variations in the appearance of the decking. Most pressure-treated deck owners find exterior-grade paint to be the most appealing way to deal with the wood. Because of its appearance, many homeowners use pressure-treated lumber only for the substructure - the posts and joists of the deck - and choose a more visually appealing (and expensive) product for the decking and railings.
If you do choose to paint, wait at least a year for the decking to “season” or dry out enough so that the paint will adhere properly.
A few warnings in working with pressure-treated lumber: Wear a dust mask when cutting or sanding do not burn wood scraps in your fireplace, and wash your hands frequently. If you can stand working in gloves, they are advisable in dealing with this product.
Western Red Cedar
This widely admired wood is a very common decking material, owing to its combination of beauty and affordability. Red Cedar 2×4’s and 5/4 boards are often used as decking over a pressure-treated structure. Although somewhat structurally weaker than pressure-treated lumber, cedar makes up for it by being a pure joy to work with. The smooth, even graining makes this wood very easy to cut, rout, and sand. Although 5/4 decking are often installed on joists 24” on center, a safer bet is to drop down to 16” on center to eliminate any deflection.
There are a few oddities to using red cedar you need to be aware of, however:
*In its natural state, red cedar has a beautiful light orange tint that is widely admired. Exposed to the elements, this tint disappears within a couple of seasons and turns to a pleasant gray patina. Attempts to use clear waterproofing coatings to retain the original color don’t work, either because they must be reapplied religiously and evenly, or because rain and sun fight their way past them. There are three solutions to this dilemma: Learn to love the gray tone of the weathered deck (it really is pretty in its own right); stain the deck with a light semi-transparent stain that mimics the original red color. Various brands are available, but frankly I haven’t found one that faithfully recreates the color, so choose carefully and practice on scrap pieces before trying it on your decking Every two years or so, use a pressure washer and chemical “deck brightner,” which will restore the deck to something relatively close to its original appearance.
*Galvanized nails or screws cause the cedar to “bleed,” which results in black streaks washing below the nail hole. This is a peculiarity to cedar, in that galvanized nails don’t have this effect on any other wood. To combat this, use stainless steel nails, coated nails, or coated screws. The stainless steel nails are very expensive, so you may want to take a look at the coated products. They are even available in a tint that is compatible with the color of the cedar;
*Cedar is soft, and if you use nails to attach the decking, the cedar will tend to rise up over the course of a couple of seasons, pulling away from the nail. This isn’t a big problem, and can be easily solved by simply nailing the boards back down every two years or so. If is bothers you however, install the decking boards with coated screws and you’ll never have a problem.
Recycled Products
There are several brands of plastic aggregate decking products on the market. The most popular is manufactured by TREX Corporation, and consists of roughly 1×6 planking manufactured out of recycled by-products. Naturally it is rot and weather resistant, and comes in gray and brown colors. This product is also dimensionally stable and easy to work with, an important attribute on decks, and one that suggests that it will give longer service and have lower maintenance requirements than a wood deck.
There are three drawbacks to recycled products. How important they are depends on your needs:
Appearance: Recycled products aren’t going to fool anyone into thinking they are wood. While their appearance is pleasant it its own right, they are obviously a manufactured product;
Cost: Recycled products currently are competitive with cedar decking (though not with pressure-treated). Judging by appearances, most homeowners would rather spend equivalent dollars on cedar than a recycled product. If you’re more interested in low-maintenance, however, you would probably choose the recycled product;
Strength: Recycled products are much weaker than either pressure-treated or cedar decking. You may notice some bouncing in your deck at 16” spans, so a safer bet would be to install your joists at 12” on center.
Redwood
Redwood is the champagne of decking materials. It is an absolutely gorgeous material, combining the attributes of beauty and strength. Because of its denseness, redwood requires high caliber carpentry tools and know-how. If you can afford a redwood deck, you can well afford to hire someone who knows how to work with this beautiful wood. So don’t attempt to build with redwood unless you are a very capable carpenter with quality tools. Redwood holds its color well over time, but because of its deep and consistent color, it can be supplemented with a very light semi-transparent stain to keep its appearance consistent for years.
Redwood also has an even more expensive and beautiful cousin called purple heart. This wood has a deep purple hue with reddish undertones, and is sometimes found in expensive outdoor furniture. Don’t even try to price out a deck made from this wood. It would only make you cry.
1248 words